Going, going… not quite gone?

Fi washing up 1989

Washing up in a stream at Sólheimajökull whilst doing PhD fieldwork in 1989 (image: Fiona Tweed)

I first came to Iceland in 1989 as a PhD student on a tight fieldwork budget doing very specific physical geography fieldwork at Sólheimajökull, an outlet glacier of the Mýrdalsjökull ice cap in the south of the island. I still remember the thrill of getting close to the ice for the first time, walking on it and camping by it for weeks on end to undertake my field research. Since 1989, I have returned to Iceland over 25 times as part of a number of different research projects, field trips and excursions, each visit welding me even more closely to somewhere I regard as a second home. Over the course of the last 27 years (over half my lifespan!), Iceland has changed radically. During the last decade in particular, I’ve noticed the expansion of coach tours, adventure holidays, new infrastructure and the dramatic increase in the numbers of people visiting this windswept geological showcase in the mid-Atlantic. Returning to my PhD field site as part of this landscape research, we can view it as a microcosm of change.

The two-lane tarmacked road to Sólheimajökull, which I first drove up last year, is a stark reminder of how much has changed. There are two car parks, a café constructed from shipping containers, several picnic tables and a way-marked trail to the ice front. I cast back to arriving here in the late 1980s and early 1990s, walking up a gravel track and camping behind a moraine. There was no visible infrastructure and no defined route to the ice. Few people visited, even though the glacier front or ‘snout’ was so clearly visible from the main road. However, the greatest transformations for me as a glacial geomorphologist are recorded by the physical landscape; the ice retreat here is phenomenal and has been documented by many – including  James Balog in his film Chasing Ice and as part of the Extreme Ice Survey project: http://extremeicesurvey.org/

Staffs students on ice 2003

Staffordshire University Geography students working on the ice, 2003 (image: Fiona Tweed)

In trying to explain this to my companions, the magnitude of the changes becomes even more apparent, along with the implications for the landscape research in which we are engaged. The ice has been retreating since the late 1990s; any frequent visitor would notice that the walk to the glacier snout has become longer each year. I estimate that the frontal position is now at least 1.5km away from where it was in the late 1990s. But it is the thinning of the ice which appears most profound to me, with bare rock slopes on the valley walls marking where the glacier once sat. The glacier snout is being effectively drowned by the meltwater that it produces; a lake has been forming for the past few years and now separates the ice from the outwash plain in front of it. All of this means that the landscape view has changed – and this is happening at other locations across Iceland.

Ice margin in 2004

Sólheimajökull ice margin, 2004 (image: Fiona Tweed)

Ice margin and lake in 2014

Sólheimajökull ice margin and proglacial lake, 2014 (image: Fiona Tweed

How do I feel about the changes? Saddened by the pace of ice retreat and resigned to the inevitable encroachment that tourism brings. But I’ve been privileged to work at this glacier over many years and my intimate relationship with Iceland germinated here; coming back is like visiting an old friend.

2016

Sólheimajökull, June 2016, holding an image from 2007 for comparison (image: Fiona Tweed)

Iceland: glaciers, volcanoes … and tourists?

Iceland is a geographical wonder – a land of glaciers and volcanoes perched on the edge of the Arctic Circle. It sits astride the Mid-Atlantic Ridge and is one of the most volcanically-active places on earth. It holds particular fascination for geographers and two of us ( Ruth Swetnam & Fiona Tweed) are leaving Stoke on the 20th of June to undertake fieldwork in this fascinating place as a key part of our Vice Chancellor’s REF Support Scheme grant.

An Icelandic landscape view in summer (photograph Fiona Tweed)

Why Iceland? Why now?

Strangely enough, the story actually starts closer to home just over the border into Wales. Ruth has recently developed a new method to measure landscape quality for the Welsh Government and the landscape research team at Staffordshire University has classified nearly 300 sites across Wales. This Visual Quality Index  (VQI), is based on a measure of all the things people love about Wales: the mountains, water, trees, flowers, stone walls, even the livestock. The big question is “How transferable is this approach?” If we use a similar method to evaluate landscapes in Iceland, does it capture those things that are important to the Icelandic view; if not, what needs to be tailored?

Western Iceland - waterfalls and gorges (photograph Fiona Tweed)

Western Iceland – waterfalls and gorges (photograph Fiona Tweed)

Why does this work matter?

Iceland is undergoing huge physical and economic change. It is experiencing rapid deglaciation with retreating glaciers changing the shape and appearance of the land, the flows of its rivers and the nature of its coastline. Invasive plants are also establishing and the nature of the landscape view is altering. When glaciers shrink they leave behind a rather jumbled mix of rock, dirty ice and sediment – changing the colour of the view from ice-white to a mix of green, grey, brown and black. It is happening rapidly and the unique visual character of Iceland is under threat. In amongst all of this physical change, Iceland is also experiencing a huge boom in visitors. Numbers have risen from just over 300,000 in 2000 to an eye-watering 1.3 million visitors in 2015, all on an island with a population of only 332000. This is placing strain on infrastructure and tourist “facilities” are beginning to pop up in previously unspoilt areas. What is the visual impact of a shipping container café in a beautiful landscape? Icelanders are concerned – we are going to see if our methods are of potential help in monitoring this rapid change. Maybe Wales with its long history of managing tourists in wild landscapes has something to share?

Typical Icelandic rural scene with grazing and church (photograph Fiona Tweed)

Typical Icelandic rural scene with grazing and church (photograph Fiona Tweed)

Our research will entail visiting upwards of 30 locations from one side of the island to the other to evaluate visual landscape quality. It will entail a lot of hard driving on gravel roads, long days and some different and interesting accommodation. We will be taking unique 360⁰ photographs, making audio and visual recordings and evaluating landscapes using a checklist of quality indicators. We will be keeping research diaries to evaluate the experiences of an Iceland newbie (Ruth) with an Iceland expert (Fiona) to consider the differences as well as interacting with research contacts at The University of Reykjavík.  Our aim is to tweet and to continue this blog as we explore … watch this space.